The History of Sexuality is a two-act play in the genre of fictionalized verbatim theatre. The play was developed through a collaborative research-creation project engaging members of Montreal’s queer communities. Findings from the research-creation project suggest a methodological approach for creating queer fictionalized verbatim theatre which (1) exposes the inevitable impact of authorial subjectivity on processes of scholarly knowledge-production, and (2) suggests, through analysis of a research and playwrighting process, possibilities for ethical consideration in collaborating with and representing others in theatrical performance.