Login | Register

Using behavior and social associations to assess the welfare of a captive flock of Caribbean flamingos (Phoenicopterus ruber)


Using behavior and social associations to assess the welfare of a captive flock of Caribbean flamingos (Phoenicopterus ruber)

Finlay, Caitlin, Weladji, Robert B. and Paré, Patrick (2017) Using behavior and social associations to assess the welfare of a captive flock of Caribbean flamingos (Phoenicopterus ruber). Masters thesis, Concordia University.

Text (application/pdf)
Finlay_MSc_S2017.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Spectrum Terms of Access.


While the four main roles of zoos are education, research, conservation, and entertainment, the most important goal of zoos is to ensure good animal welfare. Animal welfare is generally assessed by observing the animals for indicators of poor welfare in three categories: health, physiological condition, and behavior. A common indicator of poor welfare is decreased reproduction, which is a problem in many captive flamingo flocks. We assessed the welfare of the flamingo flock at Zoo de Granby using behavior patterns, environmental effects, visitor effects, and social associations. Our results suggest that the behavior patterns differ between a wild population and the Zoo de Granby flock. We found an increased frequency of preening during periods of high humidity, and increased aggressive behaviors during periods of increased heat and humidity. Visitor variables had an effect on most behaviors but did not affect vigilance frequency. Contrary to previous literature, several of the Zoo de Granby pairings were not maintained over time. Association strengths were not different from their previous pairings, or between the nonbreeding and breeding season. Our findings suggest that flamingo behavior is affected by captivity although we do not believe it is a negative effect. We recommend that Zoo de Granby investigate the effect of animal keeper presence and the effect of wing clipping on copulation. Our association findings allow us to provide Zoo de Granby with information regarding strongly associated pairings who should not be separated in the event of a transaction between institutions.

Divisions:Concordia University > Faculty of Arts and Science > Biology
Item Type:Thesis (Masters)
Authors:Finlay, Caitlin and Weladji, Robert B. and Paré, Patrick
Institution:Concordia University
Degree Name:M. Sc.
Date:April 2017
Thesis Supervisor(s):Weladji, Robert B.
Keywords:activity budget, zoo, captive breeding, welfare, Caribbean flamingo, flamingo, Phoenicopterus ruber, environment, weather, visitor effect, social, age, reproduction
ID Code:982420
Deposited On:09 Jun 2017 15:04
Last Modified:18 Jan 2018 17:55


Anderson CA, Anderson KB, Dorr N, DeNeve KM, Flanagan M. 2000. Temperature and aggression. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 32:63-133.
Anderson US, Benne M, Bloomsmith MA, Maple TL. 2002. Retreat space and human visitor density moderate undesirable behavior in petting zoo animals. Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science 5(2):125-137.
Baker A. 1976. Learned irrelevance and learned helplessness: Rats learn that stimuli, reinforcers, and responses are uncorrelated. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes 2(2):130-141.
Barber JC, Mellen JD. 2013. Zookeeping: An Introduction to the Science and Technology. University of Chicago Press. p 53-61.
Beason RC. 2004. What can birds hear? USDA National Wildlife Research Center-Staff Publications:78.
Beauchamp G, McNeil R. 2003. Vigilance in greater flamingos foraging at night. Ethology 109(6):511-520.
Bildstein KL, Frederick PC, Spalding MG. 1991. Feeding Patterns and Aggressive Behavior in Juvenile and Adult American Flamingos. The Condor 93(4):916.
Bildstein KL, Golden CB, McCraith BJ, Bohmke BW. 1993. Feeding behavior, aggression, and the conservation biology of flamingos: integrating studies of captive and free-ranging birds. American Zoologist 33(2):117-125.
Birke L. 2002. Effects of browse, human visitors and noise on the behaviour of captive orangutans. Animal Welfare 11(2):189-202.
Birkhead TR, Møller AP. 1992. Sperm competition in birds: evolutionary causes and consequences. Academic Press London.
Black JM, Owen M. 1995. Reproductive performance and assortative pairing in relation to age in barnacle geese. Journal of Animal Ecology:234-244.
Bouchard LC, Anderson MJ. 2011. Caribbean Flamingo resting behavior and the influence of weather variables. Journal of Ornithology 152(2):307-312.
Boukhriss J, Selmi S, Bechet A, Nouira S. 2007. Vigilance in Greater Flamingos Wintering in Southern Tunisia: Age‐Dependent Flock Size Effect. Ethology 113(4):377-385.
Bradley J, Wooller R, Skira I, Serventy D. 1990. The influence of mate retention and divorce upon reproductive success in short-tailed shearwaters Puffinus tenuirostris. The Journal of Animal Ecology:487-496.
Britton RH, de Groot ER, Johnson AR. 1986. The daily cycle of feeding activity of the Greater Flamingo in relation to the dispersion of the prey Artemia. Wildfowl 37(37):151-155.
Broom D. 1991. Assessing welfare and suffering. Behavioural Processes 25(2-3):117-123.
Broom D. 2001. Coping, stress and welfare. Coping with challenge: Welfare in animals including humans:1-9.
Brown C, King C. 2005. Flamingo husbandry guidelines: A Joint Effort of the AZA and EAZA in cooperation with Wildfowl and Wetlands Trust. Dallas Zoo Dallas, TX.
Bräger S, Würsig B, Acevedo A, Henningsen T. 1994. Association Patterns of Bottlenose Dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) in Galveston Bay, Texas. Journal of Mammalogy 75(2):431-437.
Burnham KP, Anderson DR. 2002. Model selection and multimodel inference: a practical information-theoretic approach. 2nd Edition ed. New York, New York, USA: Springer-Verlag.
Chamove AS, Hosey GR, Schaetzel P. 1988. Visitors excite primates in zoos. Zoo Biology 7(4):359-369.
Choudhury S. 1995. Divorce in birds: a review of the hypotheses. Animal Behaviour 50(2):413-429.
Coulson J. The significance of the pair-bond in the kittiwake; 1972. p 424-433.
Cézilly F, Boy V, Tourenq CJ, Johnson AR. 1997. Age‐assortative pairing in the Greater Flamingo Phoenicopterus ruber roseus. Ibis 139(2):331-336.
Cézilly F, Johnson AR. 1995. Re‐mating between and within breeding seasons in the Greater Flamingo Phoenicopterus ruber roseus. Ibis 137(4):543-546.
Cézilly F, Nager RG. 1995. Comparative evidence for a positive association between divorce and extra-pair paternity in birds. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences 262(1363):7-12.
Darling FF. 1938. Bird flocks and the breeding cycle: a contribution to the study of avian sociality. University Press.
Dhondt AA, Adriaensen F. 1994. Causes and effects of divorce in the blue tit Parus caeruleus. Journal of Animal Ecology:979-987.
Emlen ST, Oring LW. 1977. Ecology, sexual selection, and the evolution of mating systems. Science 197:215-223.
Ens BJ, Safriel UN, Harris MP. 1993. Divorce in the long-lived and monogamous oystercatcher, Haematopus ostralegus: incompatibility or choosing the better option? Animal Behaviour 45(6):1199-1217.
Espino-Barros R, Baldassarre GA. 1989a. Activity and Habitat-Use Patterns of Breeding Caribbean Flamingos in Yucatan, Mexico. The Condor 91(3):585.
Espino-Barros R, Baldassarre GA. 1989b. Numbers, migration chronology, and activity patterns of nonbreeding Caribbean Flamingos in Yucatan, Mexico. Condor:592-597.
Farrell MA, Barry E, Marples N. 2000. Breeding behavior in a flock of Chilean flamingos (Phoenicopterus chilensis) at Dublin zoo. Zoo Biology 19(4):227-237.
Ficken MS, Witkin SR, Weise CM. 1981. Associations among members of a black-capped chickadee flock. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 8(4):245-249.
Frumkin NB, Wey TW, Exnicios M, Benham C, Hinton MG, Lantz S, Atherton C, Forde D, Karubian J. 2016. Inter‐annual patterns of aggression and pair bonding in captive American flamingos (Phoenicopterus ruber). Zoo biology 35(2):111-119.
Griggio M, Hoi H. 2011. An experiment on the function of the long-term pair bond period in the socially monogamous bearded reedling. Animal Behaviour 82(6):1329-1335.
halmi.sk. 2015. Interval Timer 4 HIIT Training (2.4.1) [Mobile application software].
Hamilton WD. 1971. Geometry for the selfish herd. Journal of theoretical Biology 31(2):295-311.
Henson SM, Galusha JG, Hayward JL, Cushing JM. 2007. Modeling territory attendance and preening behavior in a seabird colony as functions of environmental conditions. Journal of Biological Dynamics 1(1):95-107.
Hinton MG, Bendelow A, Lantz S, Wey TW, Schoen L, Brockett R, Karubian J. 2013. Patterns of aggression among captive american flamingos (Phoenicopterus ruber). Zoo biology 32(4):445-453.
Hosey G, Melfi V, Pankhurst S. 2013. Zoo animals: behaviour, management, and welfare. OUP Oxford.
Hosey GR, Druck PL. 1987. The influence of zoo visitors on the behavior of captive primates. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 18(1):19-29.
Howarth E, Hoffman MS. 1984. A multidimensional approach to the relationship between mood and weather. British Journal of Psychology 75(1):15-23.
Hughes AL. 2015. Stability of social behavior in captive American Flamingos (Phoenicopterus ruber): A quantitative case study. Zoo biology 34(4):305-313.
Huntingford FA. 2004. Implications of domestication and rearing conditions for the behaviour of cultivated fishes. Journal of Fish Biology 65(s1):122-142.
Johnson A, Cézilly F. 2009. The greater flamingo. A&C Black.
Kelley J, Magurran A, García CM. 2006. Captive breeding promotes aggression in an endangered Mexican fish. Biological Conservation 133(2):169-177.
King C. 2008a. The potential contribution of captive flamingos to research. Flamingo, Bulletin of the IUCN-SSC/Wetlands International Flamingo Specialist Group(16):61-64.
King C, Bračko A. 2014. Nineteen years of management for Phoenicopteriformes in European Association of Zoos and Aquaria institutions: the Fabulous Flamingo Surveys and strategies to increase reproduction in captivity. International Zoo Yearbook 48(1):184-198.
King CE. 1994. Management and research implications of selected behaviours in a mixed colony of flamingos at Rotterdam Zoo. International Zoo Yearbook 33(1):103-113.
King CE. 2000. Captive flamingo populations and opportunities for research in zoos. Waterbirds:142-149.
King CE. 2008b. A hypothetical husbandry point system for breeding flamingos in captivity. Flamingo 16:57-61.
King CE, Maher S, Stevens E. 2005. Flamingo husbandry guidelines: A Joint Effort of the AZA and EAZA in cooperation with Wildfowl and Wetlands Trust. p 164-167.
Kvarnemo C, Ahnesjo I. 1996. The dynamics of operational sex ratios and competition for mates. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 11(10):404-408.
Larsen MJ, Sherwen SL, Rault J-L. 2014. Number of nearby visitors and noise level affect vigilance in captive koalas. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 154:76-82.
Lindburg DG, Fitch-Snyder H. 1994. Use of behavior to evaluate reproductive problems in captive mammals. Zoo Biology 13(5):433-445.
Linden M. 1991. Divorce in great tits--chance or choice? An experimental approach. The American Naturalist 138(4):1039-1048.
Lindgren CJ, Pickering S. 1997. Ritualised displays and display frequencies of Andean Flamingos Phoenicoparrus andinus. Wildfowl 48(48):194-201.
Martin GR. 2012. Through birds’ eyes: insights into avian sensory ecology. Journal of Ornithology 153(1):23-48.
Martin P, Bateson P. 2007. Measuring behaviour: an introductory guide. Third ed. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Mason GJ. 2010. Species differences in responses to captivity: stress, welfare and the comparative method. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 25(12):713-721.
McPhee ME. 2004. Generations in captivity increases behavioral variance: considerations for captive breeding and reintroduction programs. Biological conservation 115(1):71-77.
Melfi V. 2009. There are big gaps in our knowledge, and thus approach, to zoo animal welfare: a case for evidence‐based zoo animal management. Zoo Biology 28(6):574-588.
Mills SC, Reynolds JD. 2003. Operational sex ratio and alternative reproductive behaviours in the European bitterling, Rhodeus sericeus. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 54(2):98-104.
Morgan KN, Tromborg CT. 2007. Sources of stress in captivity. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 102(3/4):262-302.
Moyer BR, Drown DM, Clayton DH. 2002. Low humidity reduces ectoparasite pressure: implications for host life history evolution. Oikos 97(2):223-228.
O'Connell-Rodwell CE, Rojek N, Rodwell TC, Shannon PW. 2004. Artificially induced group display and nesting behaviour in a reintroduced population of Caribbean Flamingo Phoenicopterus ruber ruber. Bird Conservation International 14(01).
O'Donovan D, Hindle JE, Sean M, Sean OD. 1993. Effect of visitors on the behaviour of female cheetahs. International Zoo Yearbook 32:238-244.
Ogden JJ, Lindburg DG, Maple TL. 1994. A preliminary study of the effects of ecologically relevant sounds on the behaviour of captive lowland gorillas. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 39(2):163-176.
Parker G. 1974. Courtship persistence and female-guarding as male time investment strategies. Behaviour 48(1):157-183.
Part T, Gustafsson L. 1989. Breeding dispersal in the collared flycatcher (Ficedula albicollis): possible causes and reproductive consequences. The Journal of Animal Ecology:305-320.
Peluso A, Anderson M. 2014. The role of lateralization in feeding behavior and scratching preference in relation to social behavior in captive Caribbean flamingos (Phoenicopterus ruber). Anim Behav Cog 1:51-65.
Peluso AI, Royer EA, Wall MJ, Anderson MJ. 2013. The relationship between environmental factors and flamingo aggression examined via internet resources. Avian Biology Research 6(3):215-220.
Pickering S, Creighton E, Stevens-Wood B. 1992. Flock size and breeding success in flamingos. Zoo Biology 11(4):229-234.
Pickering SPC. 1992. The comparative breeding biology of flamingos Phoenicopteridae at The Wildfowl and Wetlands Trust Centre, Slimbridge. International Zoo Yearbook 31(1):139-146.
Pradel R, Choquet R, Bechet A. 2012. Breeding experience might be a major determinant of breeding probability in long-lived species: the case of the greater flamingo. PloS one 7(12):e51016.
Pulliam HR. 1973. On the advantages of flocking. Journal of theoretical Biology 38(2):419-422.
R Core Team. 2016. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Version 3.3.1. Vienna, Austria: R Foundation for Statistical Computing.
Reifman AS, Larrick RP, Fein S. 1991. Temper and temperature on the diamond: The heat-aggression relationship in major league baseball. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 17(5):580-585.
Rose P, Croft D. 2015a. The potential of Social Network Analysis as a tool for the management of zoo animals. Animal Welfare 24(2):123-138.
Rose PE, Croft DP. 2015b. Evidence of directed interactions between individuals in captive flamingo flocks. Wildfowl 65(65):121-132.
Rose PE, Croft DP, Lee R. 2014. A review of captive flamingo (Phoenicopteridae) welfare: a synthesis of current knowledge and future directions. International Zoo Yearbook 48(1):139-155.
Schmaltz L, Cézilly F, Béchet A. 2011. Using multistate recapture modelling to assess age‐specific bottlenecks in breeding success: a case study in the greater flamingo Phoenicopterus roseus. Journal of Avian Biology 42(2):178-186.
Schmitz RA, Baldassarre GA. 1992. Correlates of flock size and behavior of foraging American flamingos following hurricane Gilbert in Yucatan, Mexico. Condor:260-264.
Shannon PW. 2000. Social and reproductive relationships of captive Caribbean flamingos. Waterbirds: The International Journal of Waterbird Biology 23:173.
Sherwen SL, Magrath MJ, Butler KL, Hemsworth PH. 2015. Little penguins, Eudyptula minor, show increased avoidance, aggression and vigilance in response to zoo visitors. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 168:71-76.
Stevens EF, Beaumont JH, Cusson EW, Fowler J. 1992. Nesting behavior in a flock of Chilean flamingos. Zoo Biology 11(3):209-214.
Stevens EF, Pickett C. 1994. Managing the social environments of flamingos for reproductive success. Zoo Biology 13(5):501-507.
Stevens J, Thyssen A, Laevens H, Vervaecke H. 2013. The influence of zoo visitor numbers on the behaviour of harbour seals (Phoca vitulina). Journal of Zoo and Aquarium Research 1(1):31-34.
Studer-Thiersch A. 1975. Basle zoo. Flamingos Berkhamsted, England: Poyser p:120-130.
Studer-Thiersch A. 1998. Basle Zoo's veteran flamingos. Flamingo Specialist Group Newsletter 8:33.
Studer-Thiersch A. 2000. What 19 years of observation on captive greater flamingos suggests about adaptations to breeding under irregular conditions. Waterbirds:150-159.
Tavecchia G, Pradel R, Boy V, Johnson AR, Cézilly F. 2001. Sex‐and age‐related variation in survival and cost of first reproduction in greater flamingos. Ecology 82(1):165-174.
Tetley CL, O'Hara SJ. 2012. Ratings of animal personality as a tool for improving the breeding, management and welfare of zoo mammals. Animal Welfare 21(4):463-476.
The Weather Network. 2016. Granby, Quebec Hourly Weather Forecast. The Weather Network.
Thompson VD. 1989. Behavioral response of 12 ungulate species in captivity to the presence of humans. Zoo Biology 8(3):275-297.
Venables W, Ripley B. 2002. Modern Applied Statistics with S. Fourth ed. New York: Springer.
Vine I. 1973. Detection of prey flocks by predators. Journal of Theoretical Biology 40(2):207-210.
Weir LK, Grant JW, Hutchings JA. 2011. The influence of operational sex ratio on the intensity of competition for mates. The American Naturalist 177(2):167-176.
Wetherill C. 2015. Building barplots with error bars. R-bloggers.
World Association of Zoos and Aquariums. 2005. Building a future for wildlife: The world zoo and aquarium conservation strategy. Waza Executive Office.
Yosef R. 2000. Individual Distances among Greater Flamingos as Indicators of Tourism Pressure. Waterbirds: The International Journal of Waterbird Biology 23:26.
Zhang G, Swaisgood RR, Zhang H. 2004. Evaluation of behavioral factors influencing reproductive success and failure in captive giant pandas. Zoo Biology 23(1):15-31.
All items in Spectrum are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved. The use of items is governed by Spectrum's terms of access.

Repository Staff Only: item control page

Downloads per month over past year

Back to top Back to top