Abstract

Dams are vital national assets that play a crucial role in water storage, hydroelectric power generation, and flood control. Globally, over 61,000 large dams have surpassed 50 years of service, and many show signs of deterioration. With over 300 dam failures recorded worldwide, the potential for catastrophic damage remains alarmingly high if these aging structures are not properly maintained and upgraded. Further, many of the existing dams were built upon outdated standards, and there is an increase in seismic hazards making it imperative to reevaluate their seismic performance to align with current safety standards. The need for improved dam safety measures is urgent, as dam owners, regulators, and policymakers grapple with the challenges of ensuring the structural integrity of aging dams in the face of growing risks. A key solution is shifting from traditional safety approaches to a modern, risk-based methodology, which addresses safety concerns more efficiently and economically. Various, global agencies have developed risk-based safety assessment guidelines; however, these often lack systematic implementation frameworks and sufficient reference studies, making them difficult for dam owners to adopt effectively. Furthermore, various uncertainties can impact the risk assessment and can complicate efforts to ensure dam safety. In this context, this research investigates uncertainties impacting seismic risk assessments for dams, including modeling choices, ground motion selection, aging, and material variability. Case studies of the Koyna Dam and Pine Flat Dam were used to evaluate these factors at each stage of performance evaluation: system response, fragility, and risk assessment. Key findings indicate that dam-foundation-reservoir (DFR) models incorporating acoustic elements exhibit less variability in system response, regardless of model complexity and solution procedure. Ground motion derived from the conditional mean spectrum (CMS) method yields better fragility estimates than the ASCE 7-16 standard, particularly for moderate to severe damage states. Additionally, aging and material variability significantly affect the dynamic characteristics of dams, with increased failure probabilities correlating with both age and return period. Based on these findings, the research proposes a comprehensive, systematic framework for risk-based seismic safety evaluation. This framework aligns with safety assessment objectives and ensures optimal use of computational resources.